Maybe This One. . .

This is for 's Grell-o-Ween (sounds like a Jello flavor XD) contest.

After much begging, Will actually allows Grell to throw a Halloween party. (He said yes to get Grell to shut up and go away). But he forces Grell to make Pumpkin Pie, thinking it'll keep the idiot busy, for the party. Well, Grell would do anything for Will, so he agrees. However, Grell hasn't really cooked anything in his life (since he's a reaper and all). So his idea of a pumpkin pie is to turn pumpkins into mush, and bake the mush. He gets pumpkins, lights a candle in them, and hacks them to bits. It didn't go as planned, but he won't give up. (He should've just gone to Phantomhive manor and begged the little brat for Sebastian to make some instead). 

Grell Sutcliff (c) Yana Toboso